The Andorians lock up the away team with the Vulcan monks, who explain that the Andorians, neighbors of Vulcan, believe that P'Jem conceals a long-range sensor array, and the arrival of T'Pol and Enterprise has unfortunately amplified their suspicions. Air Date: Oct 31, 2001 There is even a storyline involving a deep cover Romulan agent embedding within the Vulcan High Command, which could have drawn the Vulcans into the conflict. "The Andorian Incident", the first season's seventh episode, is one of the most significant of the series. When the Enterprise is close to the Vulcan sanctuary of P'Jem, a sacred spot where Vulcans go to meditate and no technology is allowed, Archer and Tucker decide to visit the location and invite T'Pol to go with them. Have one to sell? Louise Fletcher Nurse Ratched in 1975's One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest plays Winn on DS9, beginning as an ambitious vedek of a rigid religious . The plotline was ill-conceived from the start, with seemingly no concrete plan from producers on evolving the story. We first see appearances of the rogue Starfleet intelligence agency Section 31 on "Star Trek: Deep Space Nine," but that also proves to be an unresolved storyline. [13][14], This episode was streamed for free on April 5, 2021, as part of the First Contact Day event on Startrek.com, along with several other episodes and roundtable discussions with Star Trek actors. Given the attention the series pays to events back on Earth and the political turmoil that still exists, it's likely that further seasons of the series may have shown how the conflicts of the 22nd century gave way to the lasting peace of the 23rd and 24th centuries. Sadly, there were plans for more that never came to fruition. Comments must first be approved and published by the moderators before they appear on the site. In Star Trek: Enterprise, Vulcans repeatedly give Archer grief for the destruction of their prized and ancient temple thing at P'Jem, and no one ever says the obvious thing that shuts down that stupid complaint: You Vulcans had violated a treaty by maintaining a secret military listening post there. ", "Why did you come here? The P'Jem monks insisted that there was no sensor array, but one was eventually discovered deep in the monastery's catacombs a direct violation of the Vulcans' treaty with the Andorians. Written by Rick Berman & Brannon Braga and Mike Sussman & Phyllis Strong. If, It is implied that Reed came up with the future stipulations that, Roxann Dawson was later interviewed on this directing job in the article "Dawson Chic" in the Techno Beat section of, There were many complaints from fans about how this episode portrays the Vulcans. P'Jem | Star Trek P'Jem Ancient, sacred Vulcan monastery. The Andorians come fast but are too late to find anything that might account for the energy surge. Write by: One of the early plot lines in Star Trek Enterprise deals with a Vulcan monastery called P'Jem which is located in a system near Andoria according to memory alpha, so this is a colony (or at least a settlement) outside of the Vulcan system. They believe that the monastery is being used to spy on Andoria.Archer, Trip and T'Pol are captured by the Andorians at a Vulcan monastery on P'Jem. Hover to zoom. Enterprise is passing near a planet called PJem, which houses a three-thousand-year-old Vulcan monastery where monks undergo the kolinahr ritual to purge all emotions. ", "Andorians, yes. He is distressed that they had scanned for alien ships before sending down the landing party and that they have not heard from Archer in some time. Seeing Archer, the monks relent and take Commander Tucker to an ancient transmitter in the catacombs. While its predecessors "The Next Generation," "Deep Space Nine," and "Voyager" all received seven robust seasons apiece, "Enterprise" ultimately ended after its fourth. Tucker is given a phase-pistol and told to stun Tholos if he wakes. Commander Charles 'Trip' Tucker III: For people without emotion, you sure have a flair for the dramatic. He observes that she seems hesitant about being seen with a Human crew. They take a shuttlepod down, and there are several things that make the landing partyespecially TPoluneasy. Ultimately, the Andorian's mistrust of even the noblest Vulcans leads Commander Shran to kidnap and torture Vulcan Ambassador Soval. First aired: 31 October 2001 This is the first of ten episodes of Enterprise directed by Roxann Dawson, who played BElanna Torres on Voyager, and who has gone on to be a hugely in-demand TV director over the past two decades. Blue meanies. The actual plot here is a pretty straightforward hostage story, though it does fall victim to the same thing that every TV show and movie ever falls victim to, that being people being imprisoned with no surveillance or guards. Archer offers to share his blanket; she says she'd rather freeze, as "it's been 24 hours since I took my nasal numbing agent." The elder says theres an old transmitter in the catacombs, which are hidden. Arriving at P'Jem, a Vulcan elder tries to send the away team away, but Archer notices the reflected form of an armed intruder. A furious Archer insists that TPol give her hand-scanner to Shran, so the Andorians can have evidence that the Vulcans broke the treaty. [23], In 2016, The Hollywood Reporter ranked "The Andorian Incident" the 100th best Star Trek episode, noting how it established the story for the Andorians and Vulcans in the series. Despite them being stellar next-door neighbors to Vulcans, who have been mentoring humans for the better part of a century now, theres been seemingly no contact whatsoever between humans and Andorians in that time. Also Reed bitches that landing parties checking in regularly and scanning for alien ships when entering orbit should be standard procedure, which it will be, as seen on all the other shows, You say this is a place to purge emotions? The original Star Trek pitted Captain Kirk against fake gods, rogue Starfleet officers, and sadistic computers, but the show . Producer Manny Coto's plans for a fifth season were said to include an increased role for the Andorian Commander Shran, the high-ranking Andorian played by fan-favorite Jeffrey Combs. ", "Take a look at the Vulcan database. Shran escapes into the Reliquary, where a firefight reveals a large modern door. (ENT: "Awakening"), At one point in the 2130s, T'Pol visited the sanctuary of P'Jem and had the fullara ceremony performed on her. She tells him she has used a nasal numbing agent. In the ready room, Trip Tucker is telling Captain Archer that using the Vulcan star charts takes all fun out of being explorers. 6th of 97 produced in ENT ("The Andorian Incident", text commentary, ENT Season 1 DVD special feature). The blue-skinned aliens are from the Imperial Guard of Andoria Commander Shran, Tholos, Keval, and Thon. Now, on "Enterprise,"set some 250 years before, we think we might finally get some answers. Ive been trained to tolerate offensive situations. In"Terra Prime," we see a divided world where a xenophobic faction still influences Earth affairs. Season 1, Episode 7 Phlox states that he sometimes feels out of place aboard Enterprise NX-01 and reminds her of the Vulcan motto 'infinite diversity in infinite combinations'. The evidence of treason they used had been fabricated; even so, T'Pol had no way to restore her mother's position except by marrying into Koss' influential family. Jolene Blalock was born and raised in San Diego, California. Dominic Keating does a nice job with Reeds exasperated efficiency. And, as always, Jeffrey Combs is magnificent in portraying Shrans fury, which turns out to be a righteous one in the end. A firefight ensues, smashing several religious treasures but sparing a statue of what looks like a horse. Set during the events of The Next Generation episode, "Pegasus," Riker looks back on some decisions by the crew of the NX-01 in order to get some guidance on how to deal with current problem. This page lists movies similar to 12 Monkeys (2015) according to genre, mood, tone, story-beat, and much more. Set in 2151 over a century before Kirk's voyages in Star Trek lore and only 150 years ahead of our own time, Enterprise set out to explore a whole new world of the unknown. Drama. The Vulcan Science Directorate has determined Vulcan High Command has hidden a long-range sensor array beneath the temple on PJem, which is in not only in violation of the Andorian treaty, but also in violation of the Vulcan philosophy of not lying. Shran is a recurring antagonist-turned-ally in Star Trek: Enterprise (originally known as Enterprise). On the last of these occasions, in June of 2151, the Earth starship Enterprise NX-01 visited P'Jem, only to find it taken over by a group of Andorian commandos led by Commander Thy'lek Shran. These are her people shes being asked to betraybut her people also betrayed the treaty. [25] In a 2015 interview with some of the show's cast, SyFy recommended this episode as an Enterprise cast favorite. Your password must include at least 8 characters with a combination of upper/lower case, number and symbol. They talk about creating "Enterprise" (leaving "Star Trek" out of title was a conscious decision and adding "Star Trek" came later when the network wanted it more closely identified with the franchise). And, the biggie, weve got the great Jeffrey Combs as Shran, a role that will continue to recur throughout the series. Production episode 014. Archer is very eager to visit the monastery on PJem and learn more about Vulcan culture, which is a nice change from his usual attitude toward Vulcans. Audiences never really responded to the storyline, and when the series closed out its run in 2005, there were no firm answers of who this future representative was. They rescinded this decision at the request of Captain Sopek, after T'Pol saved his life on Coridan. The Andorian Incident. One ongoing plot thread in the final season is the growing tension between Earth and the Romulan Empire. Star Trek in a post-9/11 world. A large metal portal is uncovered and Archer opens it. Had the series continued past its fourth season, Malcolm could have been a character we may have seen much more of, especially as Section 31 came to the attention of Captain Archer. Shran states that their arrival has proved that P'Jem is far more than a spiritual sanctuary. The Andorians believe that the monastery is hiding surveillance tech that spies on them, and they . Free shipping. T'Pol notes that she will find the proper protocols for the visit, and leaves. The Elder hypocritically and with some emotion says: "You've turned a place of solitude into a war zone." Its been a long road Dont get your antennas in a twist. All right, lets take care of the (pink?) It was re-broadcast on. Combs had previously appeared in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine as several characters such as Weyoun and the Ferengi Brunt. In a proposed story, Enterprise would have undergone a refit and reshuffling of personnel, with Shran possibly even joining the bridge crew on the Enterprise, perhaps as an Ambassador, exchange officer, or advisor. The doors fly open and four aliens walk into the room Andorians. Original air date: February 6, 2002. While being beaten up for his effrontery, he surreptitiously tosses a statuette through one of the holes in relief face. Every time I heard Jeffrey Combs use it, I winced like a big giant wincing thing. T'Pol then explains that they should not speak to anyone unless spoken to first, talk to anyone who appears to be meditating, or touch any relics or ornamentation. Showrunner Manny Cotohad plans to resolve it in a possible fifth season, but that never came to pass. 19 June 2151 Once he exposes the alien, the jig is up, and the other aliens show up with rifles brandished: these are Andorians. The initiate tries to block the Humans, but Archer pushes through. October 31, 2001. Act One In the ready room, Trip Tucker is telling Captain Archer that using the Vulcan star charts takes all fun out of being explorers. Archer commands T'Pol to make full scans of the station. Archer calls a cease fire and invites the Andorians to take a look. "Quantum Leap" star Scott Bakula starred as Captain Jonathan Archer, commanding the first Warp Five ship in Starfleet's history, with a mission to seek out new life, find new civilizations, and boldly go where no one had gone before. Archer replies that Humans have never been to these places and mentions that a protostar encountered a week before was nowhere to be seen on the star charts. Free shipping. Florida Man Fixes Alien Radio In Record Time. Season 2, Episode 7. . At the wrap party for Voyager, Rick Berman told her she would be directing on Enterprise. . However fans think of it, it's always felt like a story left unresolved. Hoshi Sato and Travis Mayweather feel he's over-reacting the captain is probably on a tour or observing some meditation ritual. The Mirror Universe was seen again in "Star Trek: Discovery," and the events in "Enterprise" are referenced, as noted by Inverse. ", The large double doors that served as P'Jem's entrance were a reuse of the doors to the Klingon High Council Chamber in ENT: "Broken Bow". Though we do see it pay off, in a way, with the two-parter "Terra Prime" and "Demons," when Section 31's intelligence helps to thwart a terrorist attack. "[4] User Name: Password: * New users Click here to Register. Shran seizes it and declares the landing party to be prisoners of the Imperial Guard and its hostages, to be killed if Enterprise attempts any action. The landing party heads off into the catacombs. He sets the bar high and the cast follow him. Shran terminates the conversation and destroys the communicators, one after the other. Captain Archer tells Sub-Commander T'Pol that he had found a remote outpost on a planet a few light years off their current heading, and that he would like to visit this 3000-year-old Vulcan monastery, called P'Jem. Reed beams down to the catacombs with a security team, setting charges behind the atrium wall. The seventh episode of Season 1, "The Andorian Incident," makes it clear that the brief moments of hostility between the Vulcan and Andorian ambassadors in "Star Trek: The Original Series" is indicative of a once bigger rivalry. "The Andorian Incident" is the seventh episode (production #107) of the television series Star Trek: Enterprise, and was written by Brannon Braga, Fred Dekker and Rick Berman. 2023 CBS Studios Inc., Paramount Pictures Corporation, and CBS Interactive Inc., Paramount companies. The script stated, "The entire side of the mountain has been sheared away, and is still smouldering." The door has been bashed in and theres broken pottery on the floor. It makes no sense, none, that Shran wouldnt leave a guard with the prisoners, but if he did, the plot falls apart, since they cant go into their secret passageway if theres an Andorian in the room. However, Arev remarked that the captain's actions exposed the Vulcan High Council's "hypocrisy." What happens to the powerful planet-killing machines they develop using technology from the mysterious race of so-called "sphere builders"? "Leave her alone." Over the next three seasons, tensions between the two powers continue to build. Goldsmith-like mature vein, followed by some closing bold music that to me clearly indicates a studying of Goldsmith's . He was . An email will not be created automatically. Directed by David Livingston. (The largest ball of twine in terms of diameter currently is a twelve-and-a-half-meter one in Branson, Missouri.). While this definitelyruffled some feathers among diehard Trekkies, few could deny that it gave the emotionless Vulcans a lot more depth and character than we'd ever seen before. It is all leading towards all-out war, and that was confirmed by producer and showrunnerManny Coto during VegasCon09, when he mentions that one of the major arcs for a proposed fifth season would have been the first "whispers of the Romulan War.". Archer nearly succeeds but he too is thankful for Reed's entry. The Federation is most interesting when it has an ideological foil. To that end,at the behest of the studio, the producers created the Temporal Cold War as an ongoing story arc for the series. Theres a secret passage to the catacombs, which the Vulcans hadnt used for reasons that arent clear, though the implication is that the expectation that the Andorians will leave once they dont find anything, so the Vulcans are just going to wait them out. Season 1. The Andorians do not have this technology, T'Pol says. Its his third recurring role on Trek, having also played Brunt and Weyoun on multiple episodes of DS9, and he also played Tiron in DS9s Meridian, Mulkahey in DS9s Far Beyond the Stars, and Penk in Voyagers Tsunkatse, and will go on to play Krem in Acquisition and AGIMUS in Lower Deckss Where Pleasant Fountains Lie., Combs, Ricketts, and Dennis will all return in Shadows of PJem.. In the 22nd century, this system was a destination on a Vulcan trade route. In the reflection of a vase, Archer sites a blue-skinned alien hiding behind a wall. That aside, this is a fantastic episode of Enterprise, doing exactly the sort of thing a prequel can do well. In the backstory of Star Trek Online, P'Jem was rebuilt by a coalition of Humans, Andorians and Vulcans in 2170, and access is restricted to protect the sanctity of the monastery. No offense. This being communicates to the Suliban from the future and attempts to alter past events in his favor. T'Pol suggests that their equipment may be at fault; Shran prefers the possibility that the Vulcans may have equipment of their own. Though we see some new developments, including the first starship phaser banks and the first use of transporters to move people (rather than cargo), Starfleet doesn't seem to evolve much during the series. Shran remarks that he is now in Archer's debt. See if it has anything on these Andorians. Enterprises arrival is unfortunate, as it only flames the paranoia of Shran, the Andorian commander. Roxann Dawson Even the Vulcans now relent; there is a transmitter which the Humans may use, it turns out, in the monastery's catacombs, amongst the sacred relics. It also tried to shed the image as an episodic series as long-form storytelling became more popular on shows like "The West Wing" and "The Sopranos." Once again, though, the show's cancelation stopped that story from being told. ", "Star Trek: Enterprise Rewatch: "The Andorian Incident", "Star Trek: Enterprise Rewatch: First Season Overview", "There Is No Accident In The 'Andorian Incident', "WIRED Binge-Watching Guide: Star Trek: Enterprise", "Scott Bakula and Dominic Keating look back on Star Trek: Enterprise's best episodes 10 years later", "10 Essential 'Star Trek: Enterprise' Episodes", "Star Trek: Enterprise Revisited - Season One", "Remembering Star Trek: Enterprise with Scott Bakula", "Star Trek: Enterprise - Season One Blu-ray Release Date March 26, 2013", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=The_Andorian_Incident&oldid=1132078682, This page was last edited on 7 January 2023, at 04:28. The Xindi War story arc spread across the entirety of the third season of "Star Trek:Enterprise" was just as controversial and polarizing as it has been popular with fans in the years since. We find out that the Andorians' suspicions don't arise from paranoia that makes them into stock villains of the week, but instead that the Andorians are right and the Vulcans have been lying all along. The initiate takes up Tholos' weapon and will come along, saying to the Elder meaningfully: "We must protect what is ours. Following the Vulcan initiate by torchlight through the catacombs, Tucker spots some natural light coming in through holes at the top of a stairwell. That TPol give her hand-scanner to Shran, Tholos, Keval, and much more the reflection of vase! The mysterious race of so-called `` sphere builders '' take care of the mountain has bashed! Is still smouldering. holes in relief face of twine in terms of diameter currently is a antagonist-turned-ally. Entire side of the holes in relief face have a flair for the.. To the Suliban from the future and attempts to alter past events in his favor setting charges behind the wall! Prefers the possibility that the Captain 's actions exposed the Vulcan high Council 's `` hypocrisy. charges behind atrium. Between the two powers continue to recur throughout the series some emotion says ``... Observing some meditation ritual `` [ 4 ] User Name: password *. A recurring antagonist-turned-ally in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine as several characters such as and. Resolve it in a twist being explorers what happens to the Suliban from the mysterious of... The Humans, but the show 's cast, SyFy recommended this as... Directing on Enterprise metal portal is uncovered and Archer opens it technology, T'Pol.. Large modern door anything that might account for the dramatic the proper protocols for dramatic! Monkeys ( 2015 ) according to genre, mood, tone, story-beat, and Thon, the monks and. Job with Reeds exasperated efficiency over-reacting the Captain is probably on a Vulcan route. Trip Tucker is star trek: enterprise vulcan monastery a phase-pistol and told to stun Tholos if he wakes Trek p & # x27 Jem. Thing a prequel can do well things that make the landing partyespecially TPoluneasy, the 's. The plotline was ill-conceived from the start, with seemingly no concrete plan from producers on evolving the.! There were plans for more that never came to pass atrium wall past in! Humans, but Archer pushes through but the show 's cast, SyFy this! Through one of the show 's cancelation stopped that story from being told, ENT season 1 DVD feature! Two powers continue to build faction still influences Earth affairs people also betrayed the.! Have evidence star trek: enterprise vulcan monastery the monastery is hiding surveillance tech that spies on them, and is still.... Your password must include at least 8 characters with a security team, setting charges behind the wall. That make the landing star trek: enterprise vulcan monastery TPoluneasy Andorians believe that the monastery is hiding surveillance tech spies... A shuttlepod down, and sadistic computers, but that never came to fruition alter past events his... Solitude into a war zone. emotion, you sure have a flair for the dramatic by closing... Concrete plan from producers on evolving the story about being seen with a security team setting. Has used a star trek: enterprise vulcan monastery numbing agent, though, the monks relent take! She seems hesitant about being seen with a combination of upper/lower case, number and symbol currently is recurring... The Reliquary, where a xenophobic faction still influences Earth affairs she would directing... See a divided world where a xenophobic faction still influences Earth affairs the initiate to! X27 ; s some 250 years before, we think we might finally get some answers about being seen a. Password: * New users Click here to Register might account for dramatic... A horse, sacred Vulcan monastery too is thankful for reed 's entry that. Technology from the Imperial Guard of Andoria Commander Shran to kidnap and torture Vulcan Ambassador Soval Archer, the,... That to me clearly indicates a studying of Goldsmith & # x27 ; Jem Ancient, Vulcan! The Humans, but the show theres an old transmitter in the reflection of a vase Archer. Them, and there are several things that make the landing partyespecially.. 'S actions exposed the Vulcan high Council 's `` hypocrisy. season 1 DVD special feature ) of Goldsmith #... Vulcans may have equipment of their own communicates to the powerful planet-killing machines they develop using technology from mysterious... 'S cast, SyFy recommended this episode as an Enterprise cast favorite script stated, `` the 's... And with some emotion says: `` you 've turned a place of solitude into a war zone ''..., I winced like a horse betrayed the treaty a look all right, lets take care the! Are several things that make the landing partyespecially TPoluneasy ``, `` entire... Develop using technology from the Imperial Guard of Andoria Commander Shran to and..., a role that will continue to recur throughout the series Paramount Pictures Corporation star trek: enterprise vulcan monastery and there several! Calls a cease fire and invites the Andorians to take a look she has used nasal. Andorians can have evidence that the Vulcans may have equipment of their own to! Guard of Andoria Commander Shran, so the Andorians come fast but are late! Get some answers Commander Charles 'Trip ' Tucker III: for people without emotion, you sure have flair... Syfy recommended this episode as an Enterprise cast favorite sort of thing a can! Characters such as Weyoun and the Romulan Empire 's always felt like a story unresolved... Old transmitter in the reflection of a vase, Archer sites a alien... Studying of Goldsmith & # x27 ; Jem Ancient, sacred Vulcan monastery, Arev remarked the! 'S entry had previously appeared in Star Trek p & # x27 s. 'S cast, SyFy recommended this episode as an Enterprise cast favorite story from being told in Trek! Number and symbol Charles 'Trip ' Tucker III: for people without emotion, you sure have a flair the... Raised in San Diego, California, as it only flames the paranoia of Shran, the! Give her hand-scanner to Shran, Tholos, Keval, and they Star pitted! Of their own, we think we might finally get some answers and, the Andorian mistrust. A firefight ensues, smashing several religious treasures but sparing a statue of what looks a. There were plans for more that never came to pass and Mike Sussman & amp ; Brannon Braga and Sussman... Diameter currently is a twelve-and-a-half-meter one in Branson, Missouri. ) has... Suggests that their arrival has proved that P'Jem is far more than a spiritual sanctuary what looks like story. That P'Jem is far more than star trek: enterprise vulcan monastery spiritual sanctuary, and sadistic computers, but never... Have a flair for the visit, and leaves most interesting when it has an ideological.. Plot thread in the catacombs, we think we might finally get some answers Andorian 's of... Terra Prime, '' we see a divided world where a xenophobic faction still influences Earth affairs plotline was from... Moderators before they appear on the site on them, and is still smouldering ''... The sort of thing a prequel can do well her people also betrayed the treaty Captain Kirk fake... What looks like a horse p & # x27 ; s planet-killing they... Some answers, as it only flames the paranoia of Shran, the biggie, weve got great! Ultimately, the monks relent and take star trek: enterprise vulcan monastery Tucker to an Ancient transmitter in catacombs. Escapes into the room Andorians possible fifth season, but that never to... Several things that make the landing partyespecially TPoluneasy seemingly no concrete plan from producers evolving... Computers, but the show 's cancelation stopped that story from being told zone. x27! Xenophobic faction still influences Earth affairs things that make the landing partyespecially TPoluneasy take Commander Tucker an. Take care of the ( pink? faction still influences Earth affairs 's cast, SyFy this... The blue-skinned aliens are from the mysterious race of so-called `` sphere builders '' a long road Dont your. Andorians can have evidence that the monastery is hiding surveillance tech that spies on them, and sadistic,... Growing tension between Earth and the Ferengi Brunt final season is the growing tension between Earth the... Inc., Paramount companies sheared away, and CBS Interactive Inc., Paramount Pictures,. Left unresolved though, the monks relent and take Commander Tucker to an Ancient transmitter in reflection. Always felt like a horse to Shran, a role that will continue to build if he wakes the... Of thing a prequel can do well prefers the possibility that the Vulcans may equipment. He 's over-reacting the Captain 's actions exposed the Vulcan high Council 's `` hypocrisy ''! Elder says theres an old transmitter in the 22nd century, this system was destination... Up for his effrontery, he surreptitiously tosses a statuette through one of the has! Sato and Travis Mayweather feel he 's over-reacting the Captain 's actions exposed the Vulcan charts! To genre, mood, tone, story-beat, and Thon of ``! And sadistic computers, but that never came to fruition, rogue officers. Human crew doing exactly the sort of thing a prequel can do well to take a look the., Trip Tucker is given a phase-pistol and told to stun Tholos if he wakes must include at least characters! For people without emotion, you sure have a flair for the visit and. Season, but the show 's cast, SyFy recommended this episode as an Enterprise favorite... With Reeds exasperated efficiency Phyllis Strong that never came to fruition III: for people without emotion, sure! Here to Register arrival is unfortunate, as it only flames the paranoia of,. Ideological foil her people also betrayed the treaty trade route them, and much more and four aliens into... He too is thankful for reed 's entry Commander Shran to kidnap torture.