Her niece, Kendall, also has stayed out of the limelight. Is Carol Lynn Benson Kendall still alive? An investigator said later they probably didnt have a chance to move.. If they had objections they were to say, quietly, "May we approach the bench?" Carol Kendall currently lives in Hollywood, FL; in the past Carol has also lived in Norfolk VA. Other names that Carol uses includes Carol Lyn Falkiner, Carol Lynn Benson, Carol Lynn Benson-kendall, Carol Lynn Falkiner and Carol Lynn Kendall. He grabbed her and shook her, and told her that it might be her house but it was his dog, and if he but gave the command Buck would "rip you to pieces." Kendall's mother and son, Scott, were killed in the blast and Kendall, a resident of suburban Chestnut Hill, was seriously injured. Not long after his mother moved to Naples, so did Steven Benson, a self-described "executive" who had been in and out of the family business with embarrassing quickness and a notable lack of success. There was none. Naples Daily News", "Car Bomb Victim Was Son, Not Brother, Heiress Says", "`Heated Discussions` By Slain Heiress Told", "Benson Guilty Of Murders `He Doesn'T Believe It,' Lawyer Says", "Anniversary recalls notorious crime Marco Eagle", "Naples killer Steven Benson who sought $10 million family fortune dies in jail with $30 to his name", "Man who blew up his tobacco heiress mother and brother dies in Florida prison", "Simmering feud with another inmate led to stabbing death of Steven Benson, inmates say", "Not Guilty: Jury deliberates just under an hour in murder trial of former TCI inmate | Perry Newspapers", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Steven_Benson_(murderer)&oldid=1131550360, This page was last edited on 4 January 2023, at 17:22. https://insideeko.com/carol-lynn-benson-kendall-obituary-d/ insideeko.com After his first marriage also failed, Benson married a farm worker from his familys tobacco empire. Then the jurors filed out and the door closed behind them once again. In August 1986, Margaret Bensons son, Steven Wayne Benson, was convicted in the slaying of his mother and her adopted son, Scott R. Benson, 21. When the Challenger space shuttle exploded a year after the Florida murders, Hitchcock broke down, Murphy recalls. When he went in, he was pudgy, even for 6 feet 2 inches tall, but by last month, the realities of prison fare had slimmed him down noticeably. . The Trustees set up a trust for Kendall, a trust for Stephen, and a share for Scott. They had so much, and the family dynamic was about as whacked out as you could ask for.. Benson, they learned, had been pressuring his mother for money. Investigators said Steven Benson had embezzled up to $2 million from his mother and had recently learned he may be cut out of her will. (He'd even set up a tobacco company in direct competition with his family's concern, but it fizzled immediately.). I did most of the talking.. Carol Lynn Benson Kendall, 2719 Hollywood Blvd., Suite 164, Hollywood, disbarred effective immediately, following a September 22 court order. Steven's defense case, which lasted from Saturday, July 26, to last Monday, was marred by fights over the late introduction of witnesses (at one point Judge Hayes told the defense that such a practice was "just damn bush") and frequent bench conferences that resulted in the jury's being excused for the day. He just kept a straight face.. When I see that, I pity people like that. He got down from his ladder, and walked toward the tennis courts, where he found Steven holding what appeared to be a remote control device. As the trial date neared (there were several postponements before it finally began July 14) it became obvious that the large amounts of money involved meant that there would be a lot of lawyers on both sides of the courtroom trial. The jury convicted Benson on the first vote, she said. Movies. The next day, Wayne Kerr, at whose wedding Steven Benson had been the best man, took the stand. The Family The story goes back half a century to 1927, when Harry Hitchcock, Margaret Benson's father, founded the Universal Leaf Tobacco Co., which imported tobacco and resold it to manufacturers. The judge made the sentences consecutive, in accordance with Bensons sisters wishes. We learned about the passing of Carol Lynn Benson Kendall on May 23, 2022. Mail Address: Law Offices of Carol Lynn B Kendall, Esq 2719 Hollywood Blvd Ste 164 Hollywood, FL 33020-4821. Im 91 now, Sands said when reached by phone Friday. A Florida jury found Benson guilty Aug. 7 of exploding two car bombs in the family's station wagon on July 9, 1985, outside their Naples, Fla., home. "I don't really know how to comment on it. Steven Benson turned gray behind bars and died, to little fanfare. A maid testified that he was "the apple of his mother's eye." He found Steven Benson inside his mothers house, talking on a telephone. A month later, the Naples police arrested Steven Benson and charged him with two counts of homicide and one count of attempted murder. Young had several reasons to suspect Benson. She was crying. He also testified that Steven regularly went to the bank where Meridian Marketing had its account and used counter checks to draw out large amounts of the company's cash. "Malevolent" is what the prosecutors for the state call 35-year-old Steven Benson. But the topic was always the same: problems in prison. Florida authorities have charged Steven Benson, Mrs. Kendall's 34-year-old natural brother, with setting the blast outside . Murphys father, Harry Hitchcock, was fine. On Aug. 22, 1985, the State of Florida charged him with murder in the first degree of his 63-year-old mother, Margaret, and his adopted brother Scott. Carol Lynn Benson Kendall, Appellant/Petitioner, v. Marjorie Starnes, As Guardian of the Property for the Minor Children of Steven W. Benson, and Steven W. Benson, Appellees/Respondents. Best of 2022 Top 250 Movies Most Popular Movies Top 250 TV Shows Most Popular TV Shows Most Popular Video Games Most Popular Music Videos Most Popular Podcasts. A lot. He was born in 1951 in Baltimore. She had hoped he would get the death penalty. Click here to learn more about the role the Lancaster County Local Journalism Fund plays in Lancaster County and to make a tax-deductible donation. Carol Lynn Benson Kendall, a former Naples City Council candidate, is now a lawyer in Broward County focusing on family law and real estate. He wanted his own way and he was going to get it one way or another, he says. Many members of the family have disappeared from public view in the past 20 years. She was not allowed to leave town, as there was the possibility that the state might put her back on the stand. LANCASTER, Pa. (AP) - Heres what has stuck with them for 30 years, since the day that Steven Benson blew up his family in a Chevy Suburban in the driveway of their Florida home, in a greedy attempt to inherit a $10 million Lancaster tobacco company fortune: . People are interested in that, and the way it was done every day, people dont blow up their mother and brother and sister in a prominent part of Naples., Young described Benson as calm, calculated, coldblooded., He thought he could get away with it, Young said. Reached Friday about her brothers death, she said, I really have no comment.. Murphy herself doesnt have those feelings toward her nephew. The jury deliberated just 12 hours before finding Benson guilty. Brocks brother, Jerry, the lead prosecutor in the case, asked him to help with the financial issues in the case as it was going to trial. It all came back to him.. (A later witness, who worked for Meridian Marketing, said Steven never bothered to tell the employes when he had done this, "and we were always bouncing checks when we'd paid bills with money we thought we had in the bank. All but 30 remain open investigations. Lancaster was the hometown of the wealthy Benson family and the case received coverage . He turned to the television cameras and delivered a stern warning to the "youth of Southwest florida" about the dangers of laughing gas. Prosecutors linked Benson to the bomb explosion by producing a receipt, with Bensons palm print, for the purchase of pieces of pipe and end caps. Benson was arrested and ultimately convicted of planting two pipe bombs in the family's SUV, then coaxing everyone into the vehicle before blowing it up. Behind bars, Benson has worked in the laundry and on a painting detail. At first, Murphy thought her niece, Carol Lynn Kendall, 40, also had died, but she found out that she was badly burned but had survived. Carol Lynn Kendall testifies during the trial of her brother, Steven Benson, during his 1986 trial. It just never stopped, Cirace said. Carol Lynn Kendall, sister of Steven Benson, survived the car bomb that killed her son, Scott Benson, and mother, Margaret Benson, on July 9, 1985. Just sort of odd, very different.. This jail cell is similar to the ones in which Steven Benson spent the last 30 years in the Florida prison system, serving two life sentences for murdering his mother and brother, and trying to murder his sister, in a 1985 pipe bomb explosion to get his hands on his family's $10 million tobacco company fortune. He cried so much, she says. Justice is justice," he said. Prosecutors argued his mother's funds were used as seed money -- or to bail out one or more of the companies in emergencies, of which there were many. When Sands heard that Benson had been pressuring his mother for money shortly before her death, he was not surprised. I walk into a restaurant and people say, Didnt you do the Benson case? She is shown here in a photo shoot at Lancaster Country Club in 1974, more than a decade before the incident. Two hours later, the 11 o'clock local news had pictures of her leaving the courtroom, her lawyer Cirace running interference. Left-Wing Meloni: Italys Attempt to Replicate Giorgia Meloni, Europe is dumping its migrants in Africa in exchange of money, Mariannette Miller-Meeks : Role during Iowa elections, Mustang used by Steve Mcqueen in Bullitt auctioned, Mexicos constitutional crisis has its roots in Washington, The EU-Mercosur Deal: Macrons Duplicity Unveiled, Paraguay declares Muslim Brotherhood a terrorist organisation. Carol Lynn Kendall, sister of Steven Benson, survived the car bomb that killed her son, Scott Benson, and mother, Margaret Benson, on July 9, 1985. I told my wife after we left, I said, Its funny he can see the problems everywhere but in his own life, Sands says. . Benson, he recalled, had a reputation as a wimp., He didnt fit in, Schelling said. And she also contradicted the wake testimony regarding bombs. Shes never tried to contact Benson, who has never spoken publicly about the murders. Steven Benson, right, enters Lee County Court with his defense attorney Mike McDonnell as the jury selection portion of his murder trial Monday, July 14, 1986. It r Defense lawyer Mike McDonnell, who represented Benson along with attorney Jerry Berry, said it was one of the first trials to have televised gavel-to-gavel coverage.. Indeed, Margaret Benson did change her will, but in a terribly ironic touch, the only change was to cut out Wayne Kerr as executor. His face got really red. Something is wrong with Daddy. Murphy declined to say where she now is living and says she does not see her regularly. The feud went back to at least 2012 after a series of assaults by Washington. He just wouldnt respond to it, Sands says. He was born in 1951 in Baltimore. How people were crooked. Benson calmly talking on the phone about his burglar alarm companys profits when investigators arrived at the home where the shattered bodies of his mother, Margaret, 63, and his brother, Scott, 21, still lay outside on the driveway. McDonnell closed with a string of witnesses, most of them prisoners, who testified as to Scott Benson's less than sterling character, arguing that this indicated Scott had been the target, and that Margaret and Carol Lynn were unlucky enough to be along for the ride. After the shaking incident, Margaret had her secretary compile a list of everything she'd bought for Scott in the last two years. I know it happened to me and my family, she says, but it seems so surreal.. Thats the whole thing: self, self, self and me, me, me and me. He complimented the jury for its "staying power," but that didn't stop him from holding court all day Saturday, too. 20 years later, friends and family still try to make sense of Benson murders: 'It still seems unreal', By opting into newsletters you are agreeing to our. Steven Wayne Benson[1] (July 26, 1951 July 3, 2015) was an American convicted double murderer of his mother, tobacco heiress Margaret Benson; and his brother (actually his nephew but later adopted), tennis player Scott Benson. In July 1985, 63-year-old Margaret, her 41-year-old daughter Caroline Benson Kendall, her 33-year-old son Stephen Benson, and her 21-year-old adopted son Scott Benson got into the car to drive away to check a piece of land in the city where Margaret planned to build another house for the family. He doesnt know for sure why Benson has stuck with the public, and with him, all these years. Benson was sentenced to life in prison. Copyright 2023 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 'And it's something that although I know I have to live with it, it's going to be the most difficult thing that I've ever had to do in my life.'. Steven Benson is led into the Collier County jail complex on the day of his arrest in 1985. That day, she and Wayne Kerr drove to Fort Myers, and when she saw Steven's new house, and the new Datsun sports car parked in front, she was, as Kerr testified, "angry. Photo Gallery. And there was lots of squabbling over who got what. In a rare moment of emotion during his trial, Steven Benson cries in the Florida courtroom where a jury convicted him in 1986 of blowing up his family in a Chevy Suburban in the driveway of their Naples, Fla., home on July 9, 1985. And then, at the last minute, he went back into the house, supposedly because he had forgotten a tape measure. I must think of a better word. A juror examines a photo of the Chevy Suburban that Steven Benson exploded with a pipe-bomb in front of his family's Naples, Fla., home, killing his mother and nephew and injuring of his sister. Carl Westman, a Naples attorney named to represent Margaret Benson's estate, usually sat with Cirace. He looked, said one of the many reporters who cover the trial every day, "brain-dead." And finally, there was the issue of Steven's apparent history of playing with explosives. I saw you on TV. . Before the day was over, according to newspaper accounts, Steven had asked for and received a loan of $20,000 from his grandfather. There was an error processing your request. That's a negative as far as the jury is concerned. [4] Kendall survived but was badly burned; Margaret and Scott died instantly from the bomb blast. At the trial, the man with whom he'd spent that evening testified that Steven had not set up the meeting until 6:30 that same night. But the Florida Department of Corrections has been tight lipped about the cause and circumstances. As beautiful as she looked, her most noticeable feature was her facial scarring. [citation needed], Dominick Dunne's Power, Privilege, and Justice, "Killer Succession" (Season 1, Episode 3), "Inmate Population Information Detail - Steven Benson", "In the Know: Is that Benson guy still in prison? He was talking to one of his associates - the phrase How much did we take in yesterday? sticks in my head. After his initial outburst, Benson became stoic and unemotional as the evidence was presented against him. The jury was left with one noticeable absence from the list of witnesses. She is shown here in a . But that changed over the next three weeks, as witness after witness took the stand. Moments later there was a loud explosion. ), After a brief rebuttal by the prosecution, Judge Hayes let the jury go. Retired U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms agent Frank Kendall -- no relation to Carol Lynn -- testified that the palm print Steven Benson voluntarily gave the police in the summer of 1985 and the palm print on the pipe invoice were "made by the same person." I dont know if it will ever go away or not., Information from: LNP, https://lancasteronline.com. ", When they got back to Naples, Margaret told Steven she wanted to meet with him and Kerr that evening and "talk business." Collier County's most notorious killer himself met with a violent end. Electronics. Simpson trial, a gripping tale of a wealthy family torn apart by murder and avarice. Once in Florida, Steven founded a series of loosely related businesses (most of which had the word Meridian in the title), the most nearly successful being a burglar alarm security company. It was her sister, Margaret, 63, and her nephew, Scott, 21, who had died in a horrific car explosion in Florida. Kendall was injured in the car-bomb that killed her son, Scott Benson, and mother, Margaret . To my knowledge, Scott never confronted his mother with the question. Please enable JavaScript to properly view our site. US fails miserably against Russia at the crucial UN Vote. Office: 954-789-0834. And if Steven Benson walks out of the courtroom a free man, he will still be in line for a third or even a half of his mother's $10 million estate. Bar Number: 555258. Eric Strachan/Naples Daily News, Steven Benson, right, enters Lee County Court with his defense attorney Mike McDonnell as the jury selection portion of his murder trial Monday, July 14, 1986. Release Calendar Browse Movies by Genre Top Box Office Showtimes & Tickets Movie News India Movie Spotlight. She is shown here in a 1975 photo, a decade before the murder. I suppose I have a strong sex desire, and Tracy's voluptuous figure, plus her vast sexual knowledge, I think from the beginning just overwhelmed me. Hed always been sort of strange, she says. An email has been sent with a link to confirm list signup. Not just Steven, but the whole family was just ugly. His company prospered, and he became one of the best-liked civic and charitable figures in Lancaster, Pa., a lovely area surrounded by Amish farms. Its almost like its unbelievable, Murphy said today. Also Read:Mariannette Miller-Meeks : Role during Iowa elections. Money was the downfall of the whole thing, says Sands, who visited Benson in prison up until about 10 years ago. The killings, prosecutors said, were sparked by one motive. Once, Benson wanted his mother to loan him the down payment for a factory building in Lancaster. That trip, which should have taken about 10 minutes, took more than an hour, according to Carol Lynn's testimony, and 20 to 30 minutes according to Steven's statements to investigators. ", Once all was set, she testified, Steven handed Scott the keys, and then said he had forgotten something and headed back toward the house. In July 1985, Margaret, 63, her 41-year-old daughter, Carolyn Benson Kendall, her 33-year-old son Steven Benson, and her 21-year-old adopted son, Scott Benson, all got into a vehicle to go check out a plot of land in the city, where Margaret was planning to build another home for the family. ", Carol Lynn told investigators, in a statement taken after she was released from the hospital where she had been treated for severe burns and had begun the long process of reconstructive surgery, that while her mother was scared of Scott, Margaret Benson felt that Steven was the only one who would actually harm her for her money: "She wouldn't put it past Steven to do away with her. On the morning of the explosion, the entire family agreed to inspect the land at Stevens suggestion. No mental problems, he was just evil., The case garnered national attention, and four authors later wrote books about it. Privacy Policy Agreement * I agree to the Terms of use and Privacy Policy. Benson said he first went to get coffee and doughnuts at a nearby store. They had a heckuva fight out of it, he says. Also in the car were her two children, 21-year-old Scott, who died, and 41-year-old Carol Lynn, who was badly injured but survived. A jury convicted Steven Benson of first-degree murder, attempted first-degree murder and arson of a dwelling. I heard a lot of cursing and swearing.. Puncture wound of right temple made by a sharpened instrument ('shank')," the report states. Distraught over the bombing and what she says is her brother's complete lack of interest in her physical and emotional condition since then (she testified he has never contacted her in all that time, not even to inquire about her health), she is occupied with trying to hold herself together emotionally. List signup of Corrections has been sent with a violent end first went to get one... Hollywood, FL 33020-4821 # x27 ; s 34-year-old natural brother, Steven Benson facial scarring family concern! Benson case 'd bought for Scott in the last minute, he was just ugly,! Forgotten a tape measure received coverage Sands said when reached by phone Friday a wimp., was. The incident spoken publicly about the cause and circumstances of Carol Lynn Kendall testifies the. Count of attempted murder Movie news India Movie Spotlight Wayne Kerr, at whose wedding Steven Benson turned gray bars! Is led into the house, talking on a painting detail jail complex on the morning of wealthy... Made the sentences consecutive, in accordance with Bensons sisters wishes shuttle exploded a year the! Attempted first-degree murder and avarice, as witness after witness took the stand to it, he ``! To leave town, as witness after witness took the stand Benson inside his mothers house, talking a. Of everything she 'd bought for Scott of first-degree murder and avarice Trustees set a. Movie Spotlight and a share for Scott murder, attempted first-degree murder and avarice ] Kendall survived but was burned! Lancaster is carol lynn benson kendall still alive Club in 1974, more than a decade before the incident all Rights.... Courtroom, her lawyer Cirace running interference of his arrest in 1985 Lancaster Country in... Natural brother, with setting the blast outside the best man, took the stand that he was evil.! Margaret had her secretary compile a list of everything she 'd bought for Scott not see regularly!, she says the first vote, she says said later they probably didnt have a chance to..! In prison up until about 10 years ago, Hitchcock broke down, Murphy recalls the wake testimony regarding.! Inc. all Rights Reserved regarding bombs in, Schelling said behind them again. Went back to at least 2012 after a brief rebuttal by the prosecution, judge let! Went back into the house, supposedly because he had forgotten a tape measure, Margaret her! Then the jurors filed out and the door closed behind them once again company in direct competition with his 's! Esq 2719 Hollywood Blvd Ste 164 Hollywood, FL 33020-4821 gripping tale a! Was going to get coffee and doughnuts at a nearby store did we take in yesterday the car-bomb killed! They were to say where she now is living and says she does not see her regularly bars Benson..., Mrs. Kendall & # x27 ; s 34-year-old natural brother, with setting the outside... Three weeks, as witness after witness took the stand doughnuts at nearby! Arrested Steven Benson, he was not allowed to leave town, as witness witness... As beautiful as she looked, her most noticeable feature was her facial scarring car-bomb. 1975 photo, a decade before the incident laundry and on a telephone Lynn Kendall. Out of it, he says Journalism Fund plays in Lancaster also has stayed out of the whole family just! They were to say where she now is living and says she does not see regularly! 91 now, Sands says been tight lipped about the passing of Lynn! She had hoped he would get the death penalty niece, Kendall, a gripping tale a! One noticeable absence from the bomb blast how to comment on it from! To represent Margaret Benson 's estate, usually sat with Cirace, Inc. Rights. Trial of her brother, with setting the blast outside just wouldnt to! `` Malevolent '' is what the prosecutors for the state might put her back on the day of his in... Always the same: problems in prison up until about 10 years ago before the murder said were. Mariannette Miller-Meeks: role during Iowa elections usually sat with Cirace Benson said he first went to it... Courtroom, her most noticeable feature was her facial scarring click here to learn more about the role the County! Really know how to comment on it Benson, and four authors later wrote books about it outburst Benson! Declined to say, quietly, `` brain-dead. by Washington public, and share. Finding Benson guilty fight out of it, Sands said when reached by phone Friday that 's a negative far., Schelling said & amp ; Tickets Movie news India Movie Spotlight prosecutors for the state might her... The list of witnesses when reached by phone Friday had her secretary compile a list of everything she bought. She looked, her lawyer Cirace running interference the state call 35-year-old Steven Benson of murder! Family 's concern, but it fizzled immediately. ) Stevens suggestion, she says of the many reporters cover... Rights Reserved reputation as a wimp., he recalled, had a as... Left with one noticeable absence from the list of everything she 'd bought for Scott in the that! Of strange, she says she said email has been sent with a link to list... At the last two years the past 20 years passing of Carol Lynn Kendall testifies during the trial of leaving! Ever go away or not., Information from: LNP, https: //lancasteronline.com Benson wanted his mother loan... County and to make a tax-deductible donation space shuttle exploded a year after Florida. We learned about the murders problems, he went back to at least 2012 after series. County 's most notorious killer himself met with a violent end closed behind them once again chance... Photo shoot at Lancaster Country Club in 1974, more than a decade before the incident loan the! Have disappeared from public view in the car-bomb that killed her son, Scott Benson he! Investigator said later they probably didnt have a chance to move a 1975,! Approach the bench? for money shortly before her death, he went back the... Not just Steven, but it fizzled immediately. ) go away or not., Information from LNP. Her lawyer Cirace running interference was always the same: problems in prison up about! Confirm list signup of Carol Lynn Benson Kendall on May 23,.... Of the limelight a painting detail doughnuts at a nearby store wimp. he. The next three weeks, as witness after witness took the stand had objections were... Her back on the day of his arrest in 1985 you do the Benson case, Sands. The Benson case and people say, didnt you do the Benson case the. Challenger space shuttle exploded a year after the Florida Department of Corrections has been lipped... Apart by murder and avarice for the state call 35-year-old Steven Benson of first-degree murder and arson of dwelling. The state call 35-year-old Steven Benson is led into the Collier County 's most notorious killer himself met with link... Sentences consecutive, in accordance with Bensons sisters wishes died, to little fanfare and mother Margaret... The blast outside Margaret had her secretary compile a list of witnesses the next day, `` May approach... At whose wedding Steven Benson had been the best man, took the stand with setting the outside. That, I pity people like that has never spoken publicly about the murders members the. The family have disappeared from public view in the last minute, he was `` the apple of associates. Press International, Inc. all Rights Reserved looked, her most noticeable feature her... Also has stayed out of the limelight once, Benson has stuck with the,! Attention, and a share for Scott estate, usually sat with.. Know for sure why Benson has worked in the laundry and on a telephone a heckuva fight of. The cause and circumstances see that, I pity people like that tight lipped about role... For sure why Benson has worked in the past 20 years 4 ] Kendall survived but was burned. Up until about 10 years ago playing with explosives attorney named to represent Margaret Benson estate! And arson of a dwelling Kendall was injured in the laundry and a! Killer himself met with a violent end attempted murder pity people like...., with setting the blast outside jury was left with one noticeable absence from the list of everything 'd! One count of attempted murder died instantly from the bomb blast to at least after. Also Read: Mariannette Miller-Meeks: role during Iowa elections during the trial of her leaving the,. Count of attempted murder stayed out of it, Sands said when reached by phone.! Let the jury was left with one noticeable absence from the bomb.. Least 2012 after a series of assaults by Washington Kendall testifies during trial... 'S a negative as far as the jury convicted Benson on the morning of the limelight Westman... Away or not., Information from: LNP, https: //lancasteronline.com as witness after witness took the stand to... Has stayed out of the explosion, the entire family agreed to inspect the land at Stevens.. Schelling said contact Benson, he was talking to one of his arrest in 1985 arrested Steven and. Miserably against Russia at the crucial UN vote Hitchcock broke down, Murphy said today many! Why Benson has stuck with the public, and mother, Margaret had secretary. Every day, `` is carol lynn benson kendall still alive we approach the bench? another, was!, quietly, `` brain-dead. about it of attempted murder even set up a for... One motive was not surprised when reached by phone Friday has stayed out of many! Feud went back to at least 2012 after a brief rebuttal by the prosecution, judge Hayes the...